My experience with Kate was wonderful. I am a bit of a newbie. Despite that, Kate was able to give me great critiques without crushing my soul or making me feel like she was taking over my story. We had a Skype meeting that helped me put a face to the critiques as well as ensure that we both were on the same page as far as what was expected. Her comments were thoughtful and in-depth. She treated each one of my chapters with a critical eye all the while thinking of how it fit in the overall story. I will definitely use her services again, and recommend them to anyone.